Logical consequences are similar to what would happen to an adult in a similar situation, therefore teaching students skill that they will need to be successful later on in life. Logical consequences need to be related, respectful, and reasonable nelson, 1985. Logical consequences are different from natural consequences in that they require. This handy cheat sheet of logical consequences is designed to make classroom management easier than ever. The first is the natural or inevitable result of a persons action. Using natural consequences as a discipline strategy. For example, because you lied to me about staying up late to watch tv when the babysitter was here, you will not be allowed to watch tv for the next three days, or you will use your allowance money to buy. It can be tough to let your child make a poor choice. These consequences can come from outside forces such as teachers or the police, but may also come from you setting limits on how much you will do for your child. That cheeky romcom with sex feeling gets toned down in favor of a more sophisticated approach. Natural and logical consequences science of parenting iowa. Another form of consequence is logical consequences, where we let the punishment fit the crime.
This video shares the importance of encouraging natural and logical consequences to childrens behavior as it teaches them responsibility and respect. Using logical consequences logical consequences are created by parents when there are no natural consequences. Go right to the principles of logical consequences themselves and their concrete application to correcting youthful misbehavior. Your child must deal with the effects or consequences of an action. Logical consequences by teacher trap teachers pay teachers. The benefits of logical consequences evolutionary parenting. Build the relationship, change the behavior nc state university. Whether dealing with typical or more challenging misbehaviors in the home or in a program serving children or adolescents, this venerable old book can be a game changer. Natural consequences occur without any interference by the parent. That will allow us to distinguish restrictive logical consequence from some related notions. With these preliminaries in hand, i shall be able to formulate a more re ned version of my main thesis. This method has certain advantages over punishment. It is important to decide what kind of consequence would create a helpful. Oct 23, 2019 as a general rule, logical consequences are usually the better choice when it comes to a childs health and safety.
No more logical consequences at least hardly ever focus on. However, you can see from the examples above that natural consequences do not always deter behavior. Using consequences as a discipline tool sarah ockwellsmith. An important piece of establishing a logical consequence is verbally processing both when the behavior is present and after your child has stopped and calmed down.
If youre trying to create a positive classroom environment, ditch the unrelated punishments and help students connect their behavior to the outcomes. In the example presented earlier in this article concerning joy and her dolls, joys choice to leave her dolls on the floor has as a logical consequence, that she loses the privilege to play with her dolls. Children are in a continuous state of learning how. Logical consequences are very similar to natural consequences. Disciplining your child natural and logical consequences. If logical consequences are too severe, such as when we rely on spanking or.
Logical consequences entail more adult involvement, but theyre also connected to the misbehavior. Logical consequences involve action taken by the parent. Logical consequences should be developed in advance of behaviors. While logical consequences may, at times, overlap with natural consequences, logical consequences involve action taken on the part of parents in response to the behavior of their children. A benefit of natural consequences is that you dont have to come up with them yourself.
Logical consequences handout vanderbilt university. Aug 09, 2016 logical consequences can be an effective discipline method if the child possesses a degree of logical thought. He wrote a book that i read on natural and logical consequences. Natural consequences can best be described as the logical outcome of a decision your child makes. All this said i agree 100% that logical consequences are often misused.
They need to be planned in advance to be most effective. A consequence is a result of something a person does. Logical consequences respond to the misbehavior in ways that preserve the dignity of the child. The message is that the behavior is a problem, not that the child is a problem. They arent logical, they go beyond the time they should and thus become punishments, etc. Natural and logical consequences problem natural or logical. Letting children experience the natural or logical consequences of their actions is one way to teach. This is a fairly complex cognitive skill, which does not appear until around 58 years of age. Using natural and logical consequences umn extension. Logical consequences, however, must be discussed and agreed upon among the affected family members in advance of their applications, preferably in the context of the regular family meeting. Logical consequences paperback this is one of the best books i have read on child discipline. It is a method of discipline that develops responsibility in a child. His practices stimulate cooperative behavior without punishment or reward. A parents guide to natural and logical consequences one of lifes important lessons to be learned is that actions have consequences.
Logical consequences work best when they are announced in advance of misbehavior, and positioned to occur as a direct outcome of misbehavior. If you interfere with a natural consequence it will not work. Often, allowing the natural consequence to occur will prevent a parentchild argument and the child will learn the right lesson. There are two kinds of consequences children can learn from natural and logical. Logical consequences these are consequences created and imposed by you that are associated with the poor choice or behavior. Elliott kay takes this one a little more seriously. Book 2 of the good intentions trilogy get a slight change of tone.
Logical consequences are different from natural consequences in that they require the intervention of an adultor other children in a family meeting or a class meeting. After all, you wouldnt allow a child to not brush her teeth and permit the natural consequencecavitiesto form in her mouth. Specific solutions to help kids behave 9781424156962. Mar 27, 20 this video shares the importance of encouraging natural and logical consequences to childrens behavior as it teaches them responsibility and respect. For example, linda liked to tap her pencil while doing deskwork. Behavior plansclassroom and group supportteacher tools. Jul 31, 2012 natural and logical consequences are an effective way of redirecting negative behaviors because they create the conditions for your child to internalize the lesson learned. Natural consequences for kids and parenting pragmatic mom. Logical consequences using logical consequences should result in rapid changes in the childs behavior within the targeted routine or activity if using logical consequences is not successful, think about why the child is engaging in the challenging behavior and consider other ways to support the child speaker notes. A parents guide to natural and logical consequences. Using consequences promotes learning through the natural or social order and shows respect for children and parents. Sep 12, 2019 amy morin, lcsw, is a psychotherapist, author of the bestselling book things mentally strong people dont do, and a highly soughtafter speaker. Logical consequences should not be harsh, arbitrary, or inconsistent. Jane nelsen during a class meeting, students in a fifth grade class were asked to brainstorm logical consequences for two students who didnt hear the recess bell and were late for class.
There are some basic guidelines that can be helpful to parents in developing logical consequences. Natural and logical consequences in early childhood child. Whether using a natural or logical consequence, parents should simply and briefly explain the consequence to their kids and not allow themselves to get drawn. Logical consequences require time and thought on the part of the parent.
In the examples here from the classroom, i admit i read maxs story as he stood for the end of the day and then had a choice i didnt think he might of asked for the chair. It is the responsibility of parents to teach children that behaviors and actions have consequences. Rudolf dreikurs 1897 1972 was a psychiatrist and educator who developed psychologist alfred adlers system of individual psychology into a method for understanding the purposes of misbehavior in children. Natural and logical consequences using natural consequences. Natural consequences help correct irresponsible or immature behaviors. Natural and logical consequences make sense as a discipline strategy, but often parents struggle to come up with ideas of their own in the heat of the moment. It is important to decide what kind of consequence would create a helpful learning experience that might encourage children to choose responsible cooperation. In situations where there is no natural consequence or where it may be dangerous to allow it to occur, then logical consequences may be substituted.
Natural consequences do not require parents to actively inject. In this classic guide, an eminent child psychiatrist provides c. Using logical consequences with a child who does not possess logical thought is often an ineffective punishment. Natural and logical consequences can help parents teach kids to make. Instead, you allow nature or society to impose the consequence on your child by not interfering. Buy a cheap copy of logical consequences book by rudolf dreikurs. If your child runs out into the middle of the street, he must hold your hand for the rest of your. Jane nelsen a positive discipline parenting tool card a natural consequence is anything that happens naturally, with no adult interference. Consequences are positive or negative outcomes resulting from a persons actions. Natural consequences are a very effective form of discipline. Logical consequences are respectful of the childs dignity while punishment often calls upon an element of shame. May 12, 2020 but perhaps the loss of privileges is not the best logical consequence for the occasion.
438 515 67 898 1280 1071 426 704 1170 1271 1308 1163 66 57 1645 1195 849 1429 33 1182 345 1493 575 119 659 222 966 1503 661 284 84 1002 107 1340 1046 985 946 499 309 707 631 1282 1409 1357